Study Guide: What If I Change My Mind

CONSIDER
We tend to treat our opinions like furniture: they arrived at some point, they seem to fit the room, and moving them feels unnecessary and risky. Somewhere along the way, curiosity gives way to certainty, and we stop asking the questions we once asked eagerly. This week’s message from Romans 12 invites the opposite posture. Paul says transformation comes by the renewing of our minds, which means changing how we think is not a threat to faith but the engine of it. The first public word of Jesus’ ministry, repent, literally means to think differently. Following him has always begun with admitting we were wrong about something. The question is not whether we have things wrong; we do. The question is whether we will keep letting Jesus correct us, year after year, or whether we will close the book and defend what we already believe. Conversion happens in a moment, but salvation is a lifetime of changing our minds.
READ
Romans 12:1-2 (supporting passages from the message: Luke 5:1-11; John 21:1-14; 2 Corinthians 6:11-13; Job 26:14)
REFLECT
Paul’s logic in Romans 12 is striking: worship is not primarily what we feel but what we offer, and the offering God wants is our whole self, settled conclusions included. The renewal of the mind is not the accumulation of more information; it is the surrender of the opinions we have fortified. Peter is the case study. He was the expert, a fisherman from a long line of fishermen, and Jesus asked him to do something he knew would not work. His “but if you say so” became the hinge of a miracle, and the same voice met him again after the resurrection, beside the same lake, with the same unlikely instruction. Truth, for the Christian, is not a possession we defend; it is a Person we follow. If we are never wrong, we have quietly made ourselves the measure of truth. But if truth is Jesus, then changing our mind is not losing ground. It is coming closer.
DISCUSS
1. Evan said we build up defenses around our opinions. Which of your long-held opinions has become hardest to question, and what would it take to hold it more loosely?
2. The sermon described repentance as “think different” rather than simply feeling bad about what we have done wrong. How does that reshape the way you understand repentance in your own life?
3. Peter laid down his expertise as a fisherman to obey Jesus, even though it looked foolish in front of his friends. Where might Jesus be asking you to obey in a way that feels foolish or unlikely to work?
4. Evan asked, “How small a God do we have?” After years of following Jesus, in what ways might your picture of God still be too small, and what would it look like to be open to more of him than you have experienced?
5. Paul says our lives become small from the inside, not from our circumstances. What assumption or opinion is keeping you from the “wide open, spacious life” he describes in 2 Corinthians 6?
6. “I know what I think, I know what I want, I know what I believe. But if you say so, Lord, I’ll change.” What is one specific area of your life this week where you need to pray that sentence honestly?
PRAY
Lord Jesus, we confess how quickly certainty settles in and how slowly we surrender it. You are the truth we follow, not an opinion we defend. Today we bring you our assumptions, our politics, our theology, and the conclusions we stopped examining long ago. Where our thinking has made our lives small, renew our minds. Give us the courage to say with Peter, “But if you say so,” even when your instructions seem unlikely. Keep us humble enough to be wrong and hopeful enough to keep learning, so that at the end of our lives we are known less for being right and more for being close to you. In your name we pray, Amen.